Manning: Making others better for a decade There are a ton of things wrong with the Dallas Cowboys.
Their quarterback is probably the least of their worries, honestly. Tony Romo, I don't think, is the reason their reeling nor is he the sole reason they've stunk it up in December the last three years.
On the other hand, is he the reason they win games? And why isn't he capable of grabbing his team by the scruff of their neck and dragging them to victory?
The fact is, he's probably incapable of doing this. This ain't a Romo bag session. However, it's important to place the guy in his rightful place. He's nowhere near a top-tier quarterback. He might not be a second-tier quarterback. This isn't all bad. The truth is that there's not a ton of guys just all-out better than Romo despite his pockmarks.
A lot of talk this season as revolved around Romo's ability to connect with certain receivers and inability to connect with others. It is frustrating -- even as a guy who revels in a Cowboys loss -- watching this offense play the last six weeks. All the throws in the ground, four feet behind a receiver or six feet over their 6-5 frames.
It has to be further frustrating for fans to see guys like Tom Brady, Brett Favre or Donovan McNabb win a ton of games, division titles and Super Bowls with a seemingly endless cavalcade of nameless rabble of pass catchers.
Let's explore.
Super Bowl WinnersSince 2000 (the decade this practice will take part in), there have only been six different quarterbacks to win a Super Bowl. What we have learned over the last decade is that you don't need a great quarterback to win a Super Bowl. Only two of those six quarterbacks, I think, would be considered great: Peyton Manning and Tom Brady.
With that said, who are those other quarterbacks and who were they throwing the ball to?
Trent DilferBaltimore RavensKey Receivers: Shannon Sharpe, Qadry Ismail, Travis Taylor, Obafemi AyanbadejoPretty spare. Sharpe is a Hall-of-Fame tight end, but he's not breaking off 90-yard catch 'n' runs. He moves chains. Otherwise, Dilfer had very little to work with. Most boggling isn't that Dilfer led a Super Bowl team, but that Ismail (not Rocket) was the leading receiver on a Super Bowl team.
Brad JohnsonTampa Bay BuccaneersKey Receivers: Keenan McCardell's corpse, Keyshawn Johnson, Joe Jurevicius, Ken DilgerFour possession receivers, basically. Like Dilfer's Ravens, however, Johnson's Bucs won with defense. Not a lot was asked of these guys. But as I remember, if they needed a 3rd-and-8 converted, they could get it.
Eli ManningNew York GiantsKey Receivers: Plaxico Burress, Amani ToomerRemember, Jeremy Shockey was out a lot of that Super Bowl season for the Giants. Manning had two good targets (great, if you consider Burress as such, which I kinda would) and little else.
Ben RoethlisbergerPittsburgh SteelersKey Receivers: Santonio Holmes, Hines Ward, Nate Washington, Antwaan Randle-El, Heath Miller, Cedrick WilsonI would grade Big Ben's targets a grade above everyone else's. If Randle-El's your third receiver, that ain't bad.
The GreatsRight now, the NFL hosts a cadre of quarterbacks that define the sports and position for our generation. On some level, at least.
This dominance or astuteness has translated to wins, division titles, conference titles and Super Bowl victories. At the end of their careers, they're probably looking at a Hall of Fame invitation. At the very least, two are probable locks. Surely these all-time greats were throwing to All-Pros ... or were they making others around them better?
Donovan McNabbPhiladelphia EaglesKey Receivers: Charles Johnson, Torrance Small, Antonio Freeman, James Thrash, Chad Lewis, Freddie Mitchell, Todd Pinkston, Terrell Owens, L.J. Smith, Donte Stallworth, Reggie Brown, Greg Lewis, Brent Celek, Jason Avant, Kevin Curtis, Hank Baskett, DeSean JacksonSay what you will, but McNabb's led the Eagles to a shitload of division titles and countless conference title games with two good receivers at different stretches: Owens and Jackson. Otherwise, it's been guys off the street. And if you want to play the guessing game, put Jackson on the Raiders or Rams coming out of Cal. And some say Owens was at his best with McNabb, but I think TO would be pretty great with me as quarterback. To me, some of those names are shocking as I remember their small burst onto the scene and then their swift decline.
Peyton ManningIndianapolis ColtsKey Receivers: Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, Brandon Stokley, Pierre Garcon, Austin Collie, Dallas Clark, Ben Utecht, Anthony Gonzalez, Anthony MooreheadWhat must kill opposing defenses is that Manning has little fear in throwing the ball to just about any eligible receiver on the field. In fact, none. Look at Colt statistics over the last decade and you'll see a dozen different names with 10 or so catches. Guys out of Butthead State, nondrafted guys getting big-time opportunites at the hands of equal opportunity passer Manning.
Now, Manning might get knocked because he did have Harrison and Wayne, two fantastic pass catchers. But look at Harrison's career arc versus Manning's. Harrison was a good receiver before Manning. He was otherwordly after Manning's rookie year. Furthermore, the Colts have done a fantastic job over the decade in drafting and signing tight ends and receivers with great hands. The idea is that you don't need to be fast or necessarily good. Manning will put the ball there. The question is if you can catch.
Drew BreesNew Orleans SaintsKey Receivers: Marques Colston, Billy Miller, Eric Johnson, Donte Stallworth, David Patten, Lance Moore, David Thomas, Devery Henderson, Robert MeachemBrees is a rare duck because he's probably one of the most highly regarded quarterbacks in the league and, yet, he's actually done very little. I mean, McNabb's had 10 years of utter success. Brees has puttered along with so-so, one-and-done playoff teams, putting up monster stats. What Brees doesn't have that Manning does is the premium quarterback frame. Brees is 6-0, incredibly short for the NFL. But the dude gets it done. And he gets it done with no-names.
He's essentially made the careers of Lance Moore, Robert Meachem and Marques Colston. Moore was undrafted. Colston, a seventh rounder. Meachem's the first rounder and he hasn't had the success of the other two. Check out a Saints box score some time. Brees is liable to sling the pigskin around to eight or 10 different receivers. The guy gets blood out of turnips.
Tom BradyNew England PatriotsKey Receivers: David Patten, David Givens, Deion Branch, Ben Graham, Troy Brown, Christian FauviaBrady may be the modern-day miracle worker. He's never ever had a decent receiver in this three Super Bowl seasons (the irony of the Randy Moss acquisition is that it's not resulted in a Super Bowl ring) and his running game's been largely crap outside of Corey Dillon's final gasp.
The fact is this: Tom Brady was by a million miles the best player on his team and he just willed them (thanks to some timely kicking, defense) to three Super Bowl victories. Can you believe Troy Brown had 1,200 yards receiving? If Romo had Brady's receivers, the Cowboys would be 3-10 right now.
Brett FavreGreen Bay Packers/New York Jets/Minnesota VikingsKey Receivers: Sidney Rice, Visanthe Shiancoe, Percy Harvin, Bernard Berrian, Jerricho Cotchery, Dustin Keller, Donald Driver, Bill Schroeder, Donald Lee, Koren Robinson, James Jones, Bubba Franks, Ruvell Martin, Terry Glenn, Javon Walker, Antonio Chatman, Robert Ferguson, Antonio FreemanAlthough I don't think Favre is better than Manning or Brady, I think he's the best in making those around him better. Every season -- especially as a Packer -- he rolled in with a bunch of receivers that looked like a corps from some mid-major university and padded stats and won games.
Ruvell Martin? Antonio Freeman? Bill Schroeder? Are you kidding? Furthermore, I think Sidney Rice owes Favre his 2009 salary. Rice was a guy with all the tools to be great stuck on a team with Adrian Peterson and one of the worst starting quarterbacks in the league, Tavaris Jackson. The greatest moment in Rice's career was when Favre officially quit waffling and signed with the Vikes.
The ReceiversNever The SameAntonio Freeman, Deion Branch, Javon Walker, Antwaan Randle-El, Brandon Stokley, James ThrashRemember how big those guys were to their teams? Almost all of them left looking for more playing time, better opportunities. All of them found that when Manning, Roethlisberger, McNabb, Favre or Brady aren't throwing you the ball, success doesn't come as easy.
Repeat OffendersDavid Patten, Donte Stallworth, Antonio FreemanThese guys, on some level, might be the smartest of the bunch. Except Stallworth, who's a dirty, disgusting drunk driver who kills people. However, all three went from one of these quarterbacks and wound up wiht another, finding success with two different quarterbacks.
Our ConclusionTony Romo is a nice quarterback. The Cowboys are married to him and, frankly, they could do a ton worse.
However, any debate as to whether Romo is a first- or second-tier quarterback should be extinguished as quickly as possible, because he's no where near these other guys.
And it doesn't have to do with his height (as we see with Brees), his receivers, his running game, his defense, his coaches (well, maybe a little), his college, his vacations, accuracy (how many poorly throw balls have we seen McNabb make?) or his gunslingerness (see: Favre).
What hurts Romo the most is his inability to make
everyone around him a better football player.
And it's not just receivers. How many crappy running backs looked good on a Brady, Manning or Favre-led team? How many poor offensive lines did they have? What came first: the good offensive line or the good quarterback that made his line look good?
Quarterbacks get a ton of criticism, praise and money because they are the most important guy on any given football team. Mostly because it's not coincidence when you look at a good team and quarterback that you find everyone else
looks better.
Romo can't do this. Not his fault. It's not something you practice or can perfect. Romo just doesn't have it and it's something the Cowboys need to overcome ... somehow.
Labels: Dallas Cowboys, NFL, Tony Romo